First, you tell us walking is better for the environment and then you tell us that it won’t be possible because some stupid numbers law thing? What do you expect us to walk on? Our own fucking meaty feet?! They go all ouchie after a time!
Acquire cyber-feet
Men only want one thing and it’s fucking disgusting
But they don’t have an AC/20!
You clearly need to increase your tonnage capacity.
And ditch the LRM? No way! Without them, I’d need to walk even more!
Needs more Hunchback.
Not in my scout lance!
That’s why the HBK-6S exists.
If the money/BV is there though, just swap out the Gauss Rifle for a clan UAC20 on a Shadowcat. Almost the same thing but even faster.
UAC? ClanMech? Not in my games!
Oh, we have a person of culture and sophistication here. I knew I liked this place.
Our own fucking meaty feet?! They go all ouchie after a time!
Even ignoring the square-cube law, it’s just a really bad design. If you look at modern main battle tanks, they have been getting lower profile. This is for the simple fact that not being a massive target sticking up from the terrain is a really useful feature. Even then, they often use terrain to try and lower their visible profile further. Add to that all the complexity of making legs and arms work, and it’s begging for a stealthier vehicle to drop the mech with a 105mm penetrator to the knee.
Patlabor addresses this somewhat. Bipedal mech started as a way to rapidly rebuild Tokyo after a massive earthquake. They became so ubiquitous, that regular people had access to them so between drunk/disgruntled construction workers and some bank robberies, Tokyo police had to add two divisions of “Patrol Labors” to deal with it. They’re costly and annoying to everyone. The mech carriers are two lanes wide and no body likes giving them the right of way in traffic. After that, the companies making them diversified into military and meches have a limited roll depending on the terrain. Mostly swampy jungles with bad line of sights, so the legs are useful and the high profile a none issue. High end military models are very quiet compared to civilian models.
Ah but the bipedal mech suits could crawl along to floor, given a really low profile. Tank can’t do that. Checkmate.
/s
I want to see a Raven crawling on the floor with a low profile.
A Dire Wolf would be quite something too.
Didn’t the original tabletop BT rules allow for mechs to lie prone for better accuracy and defense? And mechs that didn’t have arm actuators had a penalty to standing back up?
I think you are ignoring the very important fact that Gundams are dope.
In game they introduced regular human sized battlesuits (“elementals”), they gimp mechs pretty much as bad as you’re saying.
Let alone drones. If you don’t install OP point defence on every mech, they will all be brought down by drones targetting the legs.
A taller mech has better reach. It helps when fighting with fists and swords. Checkmate!
If square-cube law then how T-Rex? Checkmate engineers.
What T-Rex? Square cube law dealt with them years ago!
“Square cube law cast Meteor! It was super effective!”
Fuckers had no arms! Who wants to do leg day every fucking day?!
Me.
Note: like most memes I post, this is not mine. Specifically, I am not an engineering student; I passed high school math with a 59.5%.
In the same spirit: I laughed at this and upvoted it, but I don’t know what the square cube law is or what it has to do with mechs. I don’t really understand the joke and I’m honestly a fraud for upvoting it and engaging with it, at all.
The square-cube law is the rule saying that if you increase something’s size, its volume will also increase proportionally.
Ie: if you have a 1x1x1 cube it’s volume is 1, but if you have a 2x2x2 cube it’s volume is 8.
With mech design, making a huge bipedal robot means putting a massive amount of weight on relatively weak joints at the legs.
Removed by mod
I appreciate the time spent writing that, that was a really cool read :) love reading takes from people who have put a lot of thought into niche topics.
Thanks, I don’t think I like the square-cube law. Just make the joints stronger. It’ll be fine!
The square-cube law is also why we don’t have giant spiders, so it’s not all bad.
(a cow sized spider would have legs as thick as matchsticks, and as intuition would suggest, collapse hilariously on itself.
Think about any part of your body… say your arm. Now imagine scaling it up to double the size.
Your muscles are now double the length but also have to move a doubled distance. That changes nothing.
That same muscle (it’s roughly a tube) has doubled it’s diameter, so it 2² = 4 times as strong because it’s cross-section is a circle and the surface of a circle is (d/2)² * pi.
But your whole arm has doubled it’s size in all 3 directions. So it’s volume/mass is now 2³= 8 times as high.
So in short: double your size and you are 2² = 4 times as strong, but you also have to move 2³ = 8 times the mass. That’s the square/cube thing that makes just scaling up impossible.
PS: Yes, if you ever wondered how you were so incredible good at climbing things when you were a child… small children are much stronger than you compared to their own body weight.
Ohhhhhhh! Thanks, this helped with the “why.”
In addition to what others here have said, it is also the cause of scaling fall damage.
An ant falles down a mine shaft and doesn’t even notice.
A mouse bounces and runs off.
A person breaks.
A horse splashes.
Surface area decreases max fall speed. Mass increases max speed. Mass times speed indicated how much force something feels at the end of the fall. The issue is, surface area scales as a square, Mass as a cube, and thus the bigger something has the less drag it has and the more energy it absorbs as it lands, getting hit coming and going.
Fake it 'til you make it!
The square-cube law is about how increasing the size of an object increases its volume much more rapidly. So if you make an ant, say, twice as large, it ends up 4 times as heavy (don’t take these numbers as anything but an example, I’m pretty sure there’s formulae and shit). For that reason, massive vehicles, like mechs, are impractical - something twice as large as a tank is gonna end up much more than twice-as-heavy.
deleted by creator
Thank you for the transparency
I would hate to be convicted of meme fraud!
You passed with a 59.5? What school lets you go on with that?
Look at the guy that went to school during “no child left behind”. My teachers would have just laughed at rounding up.
Rounds up to a D. Skin of my fucking teeth.
Guys I don’t think he actually passed
lmao, they gave me my high school diploma and I didn’t have to take summer school, so I think it counted.
My headcanon is that mechs require a few things to be a viable weapons platform:
- Orbital bombardment is not a viable tactic
- FTL travel is cheap and easy for non-living matter
- FTL travel is expensive and/or prohibitively dangerous for living tissue
- Artificial intelligence / fly by wire is not viable
If 1 isn’t true, then toss rocks at them from space and pick up the pieces later.
If 2 isn’t true, then it would be easier to train local forces and use commando teams
If 3 isn’t true, then it would be cheaper, easier, and more effective to deploy rapid response forces of mixed armored infantry.
If 4 isn’t true, then send your swarms of autonomous weapons platforms to kill anything that moves.
I’m sure there’s a few other reasons why Urbanmechs would make more sense than the larger platforms, but at some point you just gotta enjoy the mecha
Actually, did the surface area math for a Timberwolf/Madcat mech years and years ago and they were (unexpectedly) fine.
They had something like 25% more surface area per foot than a challenger 2 does with both treads.
The bigger issues are that chicken walker legs don’t work to support 60 some odd tons of weight, and that the 10-15m height is a little bIt too noticeable
I don’t even care about the legs or the structure, I care about the ground.
Walkers would obliterate pavement and sink so deep into the mud.
The walkers would need hilarious duck feets
I’m all in on clown shoe mechs
ED-209
Yes, and I’m saying that some of them have those hilarious duck feet.
Picture a bipedal mech with a big gun that looks like rock. It has a shroud for people to hide under, so they can’t be seen by thermal imaging. It could allow special forces to exist on mountains undetected for extended periods of time.
Admittedly, a quadruped would be better for traction purposes, but there could be specialized use cases.Or the Titanfall mechs, that are much smaller than typical and used for industrial purposes, which canonically are used to speed up colonization because they don’t need a lot of the infrastructure that wheels need.
Why bipedal when it can have a support tail like a Kangaroo?
deleted by creator
Would be a Gundam then…
Until we figure out a super strong super light material you can build them out of: All we really need to do is come up with a name for it!
May I suggest: Badassanium?
Carbon fiber! 10 times stronger than steel yet light as a feather!
…
Good luck mass producing that in the correct form though. Carbon fibers, while pretty much our currently best material is so far unusable besides on microscopic application.
We did find out this summer that carbon fiber is horrendous at pressure loads. Might not be the best material for a mech.
Awesome! We always learn more!
Nah, carbon fiber can’t really take much abuse. It’ll probably be some sort of crazy nano-something-or-other.
Build an ostrich. Problem solved.
DM me for the rates on my consulting fees.
I say this too, not as an engineer, but when reading the self important downers in battle forums saying a giant chicken wouldn’t beat a lion only because of this stupid law, instead of just entertaining the idea
My hen and I were having a bit of a staredown one afternoon and she instantly and with no warning snapped her head to the side and chomped a bee out of the air, swallowed it, and was immediately back to staring me down.
They’re also completely wrong. You can go see Lucy in Chicago and see with your own eyes the skeleton of the giant chicken that would take out a lion in one bite.
Exactly. Be fun, not credible!
Lol, giant chicken (sensu latissimo) have beaten elephant sized animals for all we know. Also look up the terror bird.
A world without the possibility of Metal Gear isn’t a world worth living in.
a space elevator for
nukespayloads will probably come before mechs and that makes me sadA space elevator (on Earth) is pretty unfeasible. Mechs are much more likely.
Not really the alloys for the elevator will be the mech armor joints etc. You need something like that or you mech is just canon fodder
