It’s an interesting one and maybe not as straightforward on first thought, are you judging on silverware? League position, how the players performed under them?
Because essentially they’ve all been sacked and left the club ok not the best terms and we have Ten Hag who we’ll see about. But as far as success, player performance despite what you may think of him, it’s gotta be Mourinho hasn’t it? Ten Hag hasn’t got a clue what his style of play is and is just as bad a man manager as modern mourinho so it’s up in the air to me.
Who would you say has been the best?
In order it’s Jose, ole, lvg, then eth or moyes. Moyes had the worst pl finish but eth has had some of the worst results in the club’s history while playing awful football despite being backed
Jose
EtH - could easily become best if we improve a little and he survives the ineos staff turnover
Ole
Then the rest tied for last place (excluding carrick as he was only like 3 games)
Ole
Mourinho for me. Although it was a boring watch, we were winning things and looked coherent!
Jose and it’s not even close
I think Mourinho was carried somewhat by De Gea during his tenure at Utd.
Jose got axed for locker room tensions more so. He would have made champions. He was seen as the bad guy because of his reputation, the next manager soured on Pogba too and that’s when people said Jose was right. If that was Jose exiling Sancho the narrative would be worse I’m sure.
If you look at how Sir Alex started at Man U, if he did that today, he would get sacked.
Eth so far, and i don’t think it’s even close.
Ole’s at the wheel
Jose and always will be now.
Mourinho for me, only time I was worried about them actually sorting their shit out
Hahahahahahahahahaha,
Oh this is serious.
Everyone laughed when Mourinho said finish second with that United team was one of his best achievements.
Proved himself right yet again.
Nearly all of Joses quotes about manU have aged so well, he was right all along
And yet Ole also did it. Mourinho is full of shit, yet in time a few things he says people think are sage-like. No, United are still just shit, doesn’t mean it’s inevitable. They’ve just not improved.
Sure.
He hasn’t been proven right. He had a great team full of winners.
No I think he has.
He hasn’t, he had Rooney, zlatan, Pogba loads of great players. You’re just falling for mou pr.
And if you think any of those mentioned were at their best during his tenure, you’re falling for their pr. The reality is, Mourinho had a team of vastly overrated players and managed to get them playing to an expected level. After he left, look what happened.
That’s been true of every United manager, but comparing them all Mourinho easily has the best team.
I mean that’s still a stupid thing to say and he did a terrible job there
There was a little period of time where I feared United under Mourinho
- Michael Carrick
- Solkjaer
- Mourinho
- Giggs
- Van Gaal
- Ten Hag
- That German dude that nobody remembers