The ability to change features, prices, and availability of things you’ve already paid for is a powerful temptation to corporations.

  • EatATaco@lemm.ee
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    11 months ago

    I don’t have a problem with it morally because for things like what happened with Sony where people reasonably believe they bought something and would have access to it forever, but no. So fuck these companies I don’t give a shit about them.

    But you’re absolutely right, and you’ll be downvoted for it. I want a luxury good and don’t want to pay the price, so I take it. It’s the same for virtually every other pirate. It’s not justified, it’s just morally ambiguous. But people need to convince themselves that they are justified, because they don’t want to admit they are commiting a bad act. Literally someone else in this thread is arguing its moral imperative to pirate. Lol

    • whofearsthenight@lemm.ee
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      11 months ago

      I want a luxury good and don’t want to pay the price

      There are certainly aspects of this, but the primary reason I pirate is not because of this, and I suspect there are quite a few people for whom this is also true. In the early oughts once I started getting some money and in basically the infancy of the digital media age, I did try to buy stuff the corporate way. And I got burned by it too many times (probably 3-4, but really once is probably enough.) So now I don’t ever even attempt to “buy” something that is digital and DRM encumbered, and I’m more than fine “demoing” a game or whatever. By the time iTunes started selling movies and TV, my purchasing of content I expected to own was limited only to places that released DRM-free.

      These days, I have a little more money that I could be spending on this type of content, but Sony just demonstrated exactly why I -never- will (and they’re just the latest in a long line.) You know that there were people that bought stuff that were still in the middle of watching it or just bought it a few minutes ago who Sony/Discovery effectively just robbed. I’m sure Sony/Discovery just created a many, many pirates with this action.

      Further, there is far more content than I could possibly purchase, so the money I do spend on digital goods, I do so either with the expectation it’s ephemeral (like a subscription service - it’s impossible guarantee they’ll even stay in business) or that I actually own it, eg: DRM free. If I’m out of money to spend, I can’t find a moral or ethical reason that makes piracy wrong, and I think actually it’s likely that it benefits everyone. When I was younger especially, I couldn’t afford much, but I pirated a lot. In Doctorow’s case specifically, I’ve bought some of his books, but that’s only because I was able to download some of the earlier work and then spend the money when I had it. With bands in particular, I can guarantee they have made far more money from me than in a world where piracy didn’t exist.

      If you apply this type of concept to basically anything else, no one would buy it. If you go to Target and grab a t-shirt, and someone whips out a contract -after- you’ve paid which they demand you sign before you can have the shirt that they can come to your home and take it whenever they want, no one would do it. Or that you can’t wear that shirt into a Walmart without getting sued. Or that you can’t cut the sleeves off or turn it into a scarf later. If you went back a second time and bought another shirt and they come and take them both, everyone would look at you like the sucker.

      So yeah, if by some magic piracy stopped existing tomorrow, I wouldn’t suddenly be a Sony/Discovery customer, I’d just take up woodworking or some shit. While some piracy is probably always going to exist that’s as you describe, piracy is a service problem.

      • EatATaco@lemm.ee
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        11 months ago

        That was just a long winded way - s very long winded way - of demonstrating my point. Don’t get me wrong, weve followed a similar path and probably a major reason why we both say “fuck these assholes” and don’t feel bad about it.

        But at the end of the day you said nothing to change the point that this is a luxury good you want, but don’t want to pay the price, so you take it.