While it would be easy to dismiss this as CrimethInc [hereforth the Outlet] cautiously mitigating any potential liability if self-immolation generalizes, the rejection of the framework of martyrdom demands attention. The question is not whether Aaron qualifies as a shahid within the Palestinian context, although demonstrators in Yemen have proclaimed Aaron a “martyr of humanity” and an argument can be made for him having become an anarchist martyr in the lineage of Louis Lingg, Avalon, and Mikhail Vasilievich Zhlobitsky. The bigger issue: the Outlet’s assertion that an individual’s death, particularly in the context of the US, is the “worst of all possible certainties” reveals a deep disconnect with the context of this entire decolonial struggle. In the days following October 7th, anti-colonial anarchist thinkers such as Zoé Samudzi argued that the figure of the martyr marked a fundamental contradiction for the secular left’s ability to fully comprehend and act in solidarity with the Palestinian resistance. The martyrs constitute a force in the present for all who live and continue to struggle. Aaron framed his self-immolation as “not that extreme” compared to the ascension to martyrdom of tens of thousands in Gaza. By implying that Aaron’s choice was too extreme, the Outlet dishonors the reality of the struggle within Palestine and undercuts the potential of Aaron’s sacrifice.
What is happening: the attention is really drawn away from Palestine where it was meant to be directed. Instead people are yet again discussing one person and in that context argue about what Anarchism should or shouldn’t be.
If Anarchism is to serve life then we have to get over ourselves, and our importance, and the importance of single persons, and honor the work of the collective and the community of the living.
I don’t mean to dishonor the dead by my suggestion to shift focus. I am writing as someone who, a long time ago, really didn’t want to be alive in the face of so much dystopia everywhere, but who is still around after all to act and nurture the good things. I am sad that those who decided to part early are no longer with us.