Funny that, I agree with all of them (some more than others) EXCEPT the last one. And it’s a HARD DISAGREE.
The true Ronaldo was amazing before injury. He was odds-on to become the absolute GOAT, with only the “strictly striker” tax as a hindrance. But all about him was incredible, with and without the ball, powering it or finessing it, carrying the ball or striking it.
I think Ronaldinho reached his absolute ceiling at his peak at Barcelona. He went from being one of the best, and a bit of a “highlights merchant” just a bit better than say Denilson, to being very clearly the best player in the world for two-three years. I go with three because after a couple of months at FCB he was already it and even more “carrying the team”. It was an amazing growth. What if? He might have kept it up for what, a year or two being more professional? I actually doubt it. And his impact on games not being at that physical peak did hinder him a lot.
I don’t know, maybe it’s coming from a country with a lot of Futsal that has seen glorious Futsal players not cut the mustard at XIs.
But I’ll leave it at… Ronaldo Nazario had his career ending injury at what? 22? And was banging them in at elite level over 30, but limping. Ronaldinho dropped his level at what, 26-27? And then had a better physique than peak Maradona. And would anyone rate Ronaldinho over Ronaldo as a player? So the big what if is, what if there’s no leg break?
Unless you mean what if Ronaldinho didn’t sign for Barcelona? Would he have been considered the best player in the world at some point? Don’t get me wrong, I think Ronaldinho’s game raised the game of the squad, not the other way round. And Ronaldo’s FCB served pretty dire football. But it was that signing that had an enormous effect in him.
Luis Enrique. Very few skills, just running about. But that’s not the only thing, Gattuso was amazing and you can see more skillful players in any park.
Thing is that when the game needed slowing down and calm he sped it up, when the play dictated a fast pace he would step on the ball and look around and kill all momentum. It’s a wonder he became a decent coach. And the worst is that he opened the door for abominations like Angulo and the like (and he was one of the best.
The funny thing is that when he was a young kid breaking through the Sporting Gijón team as a second striker I really rated him. Then he went to Real Madrid and I think somebody there and at Barcelona saw his potential to make the “Bakero” journey. And no. Lots of success at FCB, great athlete. But no, no, no.