To balance the books, Sylvinho. A strike that out-RobertoCarlossed Roberto Carlos’ strike at Le Tournoi.

Some worthy contenders for this question, aside from others already mentioned in this thread:

Matty Phillips for QPR against Crystal Palace.

Erik Edman for Tottenham against Liverpool

Charlie Daniels for Bournemouth against Man City

Alex Tettey for Norwich against Sunderland

Claus Jensen for Charlton against Arsenal