consider these attributes.
set piece wizardry, close control, passing range, shooting technique, crossing, passing vision, off ball movement, first touch, skill moves, overall dribbling, 2 footedness.
I think Baggio, Henry, Maradona, Neymar, Figo, Cruyff are up there. more options as well but you guys go ahead
cristiano. before 2016 he was an absolute monster and the most complete attacker itw. had every aspect you would want in an attacker and more.